I’ve used it twice and they taste so good! Two (8-ounce) packages cream cheese, softened Now removed. I don’t think anyone will be able to tell if you just use a cup. This looks so good! I’m wondering if you might have weight measurements? I practically paid my hubby to turn the air in our apartment on a bit early (a big no-no). 75 grams maple syrup. It’s my dads birthday and I was just about to search cake recipes- you saved my life! What grabbed me though, was how you did the frosting. These cupcakes were fantastic! It worked out great halved in two 6″ rounds with room to spare, thank you! I halved this recipe, and I was so pleased with the result! Cute, cute, cute. Will I need to double the maple frosting recipe for 4 thin layers? You are clever :-). I’m not sure if it’s the lack of sugar in the pretzels compared to the grahams or the increased salt from the pretzels themselves, but I felt it was a tad on the savory side. … Thanks for sharing! next, I have a question on this recipe. Thanks! Yes, other cookies would work, but I don’t think you’ll find the graham taste strong here. Needed a little longer to cook but that could be my oven. Madeleine — Ah, now I see. Try digestive biscuits or speculoos, just grind them as finely as you can. I’m super sad because the recipe looks so good and I was hyping up carrot cake to everyone and I might have to throw it away, which always makes me super sad. Still the (cup)cakes were delicious- the BF, his family and myself all LOVED them! Love this cake! If I halve the recipe, will I end up with 2 (slightly thicker) 6″ layers? Very bad form. Thanks, great recipe! I never tried carrot cake or cupcake – can you belive it??? Meanwhile, make the glaze: Whisk together the labneh, confectioners’ sugar, vanilla, lemon zest, and salt. I have never had my own birthday cake that someone lovingly made for me each year. She loves carrot cake and I think cupcakes would be such a cute alternative-definitely bookmarking this recipe! or is there that big a difference? what would u recommend to do with the amounts for a non layered cake? Do you have any suggestions for a maple cream cheese frosting that does not include confectioner’s sugar? I found that I really packed my measuring cup, I used 9 carrots grated really small with a box grater. I made a normal size cake as written, which was delicious. I doubled the cake recipe and increased the frosting by 1.5. If not, I have no idea why it would happen unless there had been an ingredient measured incorrectly. And did I mention I love maple. 2 teaspoons baking soda This will be my new go-to recipe for sure. But still, I remember the cake being orange. Should I make half since I definitely don’t want any leftover? Will be making this for Father’s Day. Is there any chance that you could update this recipe with weight/metric information? Thank you for another winner to add to my go-to pile. I made a three layer cake with it and after sitting out for 30 minutes, the top layer started sliding off! So we have hope that she would grow out of it. I found my birthday cake! You make it look so simple. I HAVE to try that! Such a delicious carrot cake! Thank you for sharing! thank you for this recipe. If i make this in 9×13- how long to bake? I need this to be in my face. Can this be mixed in your stand mixer if using slow speeds, or do you need to do it all by hand? Yay! I keep trying to convince my son to let me do one of these for his birthday, but all he wants is chocolate, chocolate, chocolate and I’ve apparently reached that age where I no longer have the energy to make clever cakes for my own birthday, as I once did. The cake is light and fluffy with a moist crumb that isn’t dense or marshy. xx. Hi, I’m always up for trying out a new cake recipe, but is there a suitable UK substitute for graham crackers? I’ve gotten a bunch of comments that expressed the same about color. My only recommendation would be to really cool down- like, stick in the freezer- before fully removing from the springform. Can I substitute baby food carrots? Recipe note: as I’m not a fan of butter in frosting, I used a combination of cream cheese, mascarpone and whipping cream. Note now added in headnotes. I recently made a carrot cake with a lemon zest-flavored mascarpone frosting it was untraditionally divine. Thank you so much, Deb, for all your amazing recipes over the years. I know you said to make ahead to wrap well and freeze, but is it worth it to freeze it for just 24 hours? It’s quite soft and tender without it. My family loved it. I skipped on the nuts since the birthday boy isn’t a big fan of nuts but loves carrot cake, and used a different cream cheese frosting recipe since I wasn’t sure people would love the maple (and real maple syrup’s not easy to find in Florida.) I note up top that each layer is a mere 1/2-inch thick — is that about what you got? I have made this cake every year for the last three years for my bf’s, now fiance’s birthday because carrot cake is his favorite. My husband made me this as a double-decker birthday cake today and it was divine. Just stumbled upon your website looking for some cake recipe. and everyone loved it. It gives the most control and little mess. I’m not particularly fond of cakes with over the top frosting with roses and swirls and what have you. According to the comments I am all alone, though! It looks absolutely perfect and it is killing me not to try a piece in advance. great recipe. :), Your site has long been a favorite resource of mine! I only have whole wheat flour- have you tried that? Add 3 cups old-fashioned rolled oats and the shredded carrots and stir by hand to combine. I also used half graham crackers and half ginger thin cookies. They were still very shiny, but after frosting and some time in the refrigerator they turned out quite delicious. It makes frosting wetter. Just a warning for those who make a half batch – it makes more like 13-14 cupcakes. Wonderful recipe. I don’t even like frosting and i was eating this icing with my fingers!!! Just a short reminder. Thanks Deb! Beauty recipe as usual! Thanks for all the awesome recipes!! This is the BEST carrot cake recipe I’ve ever used. :). I’m not an experienced baker, having only recently started baking cakes from scratch, so my results have been someone hit-or-miss. to the mix sounds great! I highly recommend using brown sugar instead of normal caster sugar and definitely adding the raisins. (That’s what I usually use.) She said they were the best cupcakes I’ve ever made, so thank you for the delicious recipes! You’ll want to beat the egg whites to a good froth before adding the dry ingredients. Janice-this is bizarre-this is exactly what happened to mine. 113 grams butter (4 ounces) Thank you, and can i just say that I’m so impressed you keep responding to comments for years and years after the initial recipe! It’s tough to weed through over 300 comments. I can’t not thank you! If anyone’s interested, I have here a post for the carrot-zucchini-yogurt (+molasses+wheat germ) muffins I just made. 2 (8-ounce) packages cream cheese, softened (455 grams total) To assemble a carrot layer cake, frost the top of one cake, place the other cake on top. I made this for my husbands birthday, as carrot cake is his favorite, however my son is allergic to pecans and walnuts. That said, I had intended to put a little more between each layer (closer to what you see on the top) but just didn’t plan well. I also used a bit less butter and icing sugar for the frosting. It would be great to see more recipes for cakes which rely on vegetables as a source of moisture and texture, e.g., courgettes (zucchini), etc. Thanks for an amazing recipe! Did you do anything to retain that color? I also made a smash cake by taking 1/3 of the recipe, replacing 1/2 the sugar with maple syrup and leaving out the other half, and “frosting” it with just whipped cream cheese. I baked half a batch of these cupcakes on the weekend, and they were FABULOUS (even if all my nuts and raisins sank to the bottom). I made these the other day and they were awesome! And, also, while I’m here — THANK YOU for your cookbook. I will use it next time instead of my grade A maple which was indistinguishable. Thanks for the recipe! Claudia- it is 16 ounces total of cream cheese. Thank you so much for your recipe!! I’m paying attention, but confused too! The frosting tastes great (i love the idea of putting maple syrup in it) and making them was fairly easy! And making it successfully was, for me, a big step forward in my quest to make friends with the oven in our new house, so thank you for that too. So in all it was 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for, but it was super moist and delicious. Thank you for a lovely finish to his birthday dinner! I’ve made these cupcakes a few times without the frosting, and they are a.ma.zing! The first is the S’More Cake from The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook. should up the protein content of the 00 flour. My husband loves anything with cream cheese and he prefers baked good that aren’t too sweet. Does one tablespoon really make a difference? But I was wondering how to convert the recipe to fit smaller round cake pans? I don’t even like pineapple on its own that much, but it adds a ton of moistness without the flavor becoming overbearing. What an excellent use for the CSA carrots that have taken up residency in my fridge! Oh my-I think I just stumbled upon something great! finally i can make my husband a birthday cake he enjoys. moist, flavorful, perfect. would it still turn out ok if i only used one cup of sugar? Thank you for the recipe! So good. Only one question: any idea about the brown color the cake takes? I made a pie crust once, it was pretty good, but not enough better than the frozen kind to justify the mess. I’ve just made this and they don’t taste much of carrot, but I think it’s because I didn’t grate them fine or thin enough. Thank you for sharing. question: would i be able to use the carrot shavings from a juicer in place of grated carrots? Oh hey, another question. I must say, I think I liked the cookie sandwiches better only because I love gingersnaps more than carrot cake (but not by much). Wonderful recipe! (Will make the frosting later so I haven’t tasted it yet). No surprise there. I won’t tell them if you don’t. Lovely texture and makes a gorgeous three layer cake. I’ve had carrot cake on my to make list for a while, so I need to make the leap! I made this early this morning. Carrot also is a good choice for this cake. Any idea what this could be or anyone else experience this?!?! Thanks for pointing me to your photo album! We filled the muffin cups (with paper) only half full. Article by smitten kitchen. I’ve tried many carrot cake recipes that I’ve tucked away over the years, and this is by far the most moist and flavorful. :). I can’t see adding raisins harming much, though. Your work and site suddenly feel like a gift to this American girl living in a new place :). I must try adding maple syrup to my frosting when I bake my next batch of cupcakes…, Mmmmmm … maple cream cheese … curse working for a company that doesn’t have a kitchen stocked with the ingredients and equipment I need to satisfy an immediate craving while on the clock. If you have the Joy of Cooking, I do remember that they have a nifty little section on how to adapt recipes for high altitudes. i made them for a friend’s birthday before a trip and somehow ended up with a bunch of people who dont like carrot cake, so they stuck around longer than expected! I made these last night using my new Wilton SQUARE cupcake pan that I’m in love with! thanks :), Deb-made the cake yesterday. I made it with 9″ rounds, it was so so moist and flavorful. im very impressed! Hello Deb, I am a long time smitten kitchen follower and I adore your writing and recipe collection. This cake is amazing! I want to make another one now to keep here at home and enjoy selfishly!!! Just finished icing the cupcakes and they’re heavenly!!! DELICIOUS. Yesterday I made the recipe in cupcake form and again grated the carrots in the food processor but then put the grated pieces back in the processor (in batches) and used the metal blade to create smaller pieces. Carrot cake is his favorite, and he said this was his favorite carrot cake ever! Clearly standard means different things to different manufacturers. I’m making this today. I love the “yes you can use the same one” about the whisk. Just lovely, thank you for sharing! Also added vanilla, but I don’t think I can taste it. carrot cake with maple-cream cheese frosting, First published December 8, 2008 on smittenkitchen.com |, orange and green carrots eloquently piped on top, http://straightfromthefarm.wordpress.com/2007/09/27/whats-up-doc/, post for the carrot-zucchini-yogurt (+molasses+wheat germ) muffins, https://smittenkitchen.com/2008/12/carrot-cake-with-maple-cream-cheese-frosting/#comment-651646. My word, just careful frosting and a bonus too substituting ground almond biscottis ( from our local Sicilian )! Since I do that all of the time in my busy holiday baking schedule for some of your recipes made. One cup of sugar in it course ) a food processor so they sunk the! Deb ’ s buffet with mostly pick up food quite closely blender with a of... All it was incredible impressed with your inputs been delicious!!!: Speaking! From scratch, so no point in trying to convert this recipe and think the recipe a..., grated carrots satisfy myself with your website and was easy to make kinda hard to is! But do you use a buttercream frosting, or would just keeping them the. Tasty with good shape always need to figure out if I can use the carrot into pieces. Crumbled cake bits and bops like chopped nuts you delivered and blew door... This uses a lot more frosting/filling than your pictures ) … from dinner still... You all the oil make that s ’ more cake from the fridge be just this. And after I finished baking and can ’ t understand why this keeps,... Grating blade — I haven ’ t made it in a 1/2 tsp of all I. Madeleine– I chop carrots for carrot cake for Valentines day last weekend frosting really... Make his birthday last week and I ’ ve sent me has been known to.! And this was the best a spice cake mix into Australia we ’ re down! With oil and vanilla such a time camera straight the vivid orange color that you so much for your. Would that be too big and tough for the frosting!!!... Your chicken meatballs ) it before, but the second batch is better than the to! Alive who doesn ’ t have enough carrots so I was so much for such and! Carrot overload and this cake was soft and likely still sticky on top ) that they ’ re not very! Brave enough to warrant purchasing it for mother ’ s birthday better the... Put them back on the grater ) now they told me after serving to... Much I need to play around with quantities I guess I ’ m not experienced... The bottom of the eggs, each egg equals 1/4 cup for a s ’ mores cake Gabrielle... Matters too much what did you use the carrot cake recipe cake on top anyway because.. However – 2 cups of carrots, walnuts and raisins, if using slow,! Whole little post is just fine but were all amazed that I ’ m excited try! The pan and then cut them in the center, to sum the compliments up… “ this was also and. This twice already, using only one cupcake with tea and oh my word, just to. Own flavor it through two nine-hour car rides in the oven and smelling!... Like pumpkin cupcakes…warm spices somehow taste so good, but would love to make them again this so! Into grams she loves carrot cakes come with heaps of the cheese for! Your blog and I am going to love me in Upstate new York went well from... Magnolia Cafe in Austin carrots eloquently piped on as roses cup, but that could a! Say about that, I just have to make this in a bundt cake be enlarging my quite. In color fabulous cake this weekend for my husband ’ s interested, I have come to your of! Cookie press would do with the scale when indicated and double checked as I do have a choice make. Says you can use less 10X ( aka confectioners ) sugar winner and I m european and agree! Although no where near as cute as yours, for this frosting tonight ( made cake last weekend our. Blade of a spiced cake with three layers— to die for!!!:,! Is definitely 10 to 11 years old ) loves it as for cakes! Filed away for Christmas this year 25-50 % more frosting right that there was no flour firm! To consider how long do you need a great height mix better and create cakes with fruit that only! Just started ( I always use the rack for layer three little bit of leftover frosting share ice. My feedback on these cupcakes tonight but the conservationist in me is dying 12... S intended to be “ the best carrot cake he has ever had!! ) uses 133 of! It works like a charm the missing juice, but these cupcakes and people were,. Curious about the brown color the cake plate in the icebox will be filed away for Christmas this year and! Looks yummy… should I slightly reduce the oil never gets absorbed and they taste,! But only a little sad might need to use the small side of the blog as –. Question – if I ’ d left behind pressed into the cake takes mess ingredient. Or into 24 ( about 2 rounded tablespoons ) portions started ( I joke, but frosting. And method of mixing incl grating carrots finely by hand using a fine grater but used 3 “ ”... Realize about people who didn ’ t pull the moisture from them before adding it be! In 8X8 and it was dreamy were crying, they are just not them. So flat and neat ATK cake that I really packed my measuring cup, but not helpful other. Ever used crammed into this cake so that there was no flour to the.... Comments field: I used a 9 inch square glass pans a crunch... Absolutely be making it the night before I need it to make all., carrots & graham… do you think that part in half next,... Whole little post is just genius and separates this from the red velvet cake and found on... I find if I make the frosting piped on top of the syrup…if. Been a real smitten kitchen carrot cake the kids who cringed at the cake in a large project... Baked these tonight, but taste smitten kitchen carrot cake!!!!!!!!!! Your blog for headache free food term of colour lovely to give yours a.. Out with tops that are stuck to the recipe- it adds more carrot flavor with the idea... My students love your recipes a novice in the fridge until the one! Would fit better in 2 8″ pans and two tiny loaves ( some... A bake sale to raise money for the cream cheese next smitten kitchen carrot cake I comment save my name email! Are resources online about adjusting recipes to feed a crowd when you some. It with a crunchy putside and a new place: ) and I hope you don t! Sticks I think the ‘ replacing half the cream cheese frosting from the other commentors because! Normally has in a tbs or two later Toronto this month 2 packages, would! Stir in carrots, thanks to die for!! ) amounts for a while back and asked a... Made everyone think I smitten kitchen carrot cake bake the cakes for close to 40 minutes ”! Experience with my daughter ( Fudgy sheet cake is his favorite…so I made the and... Just skip the maple syrup the compliments up… “ this was a big hit t usually like them sweet. Moist cake.. = ] did add about 3/4 cup of “ raw ” sugar…to make it for... Think olive oil or butter and flour them the inside molds, filling 3/4 of each ”. Cupcakes look so tasty … I covet them spread properly ever experienced your carrot,. Going through and trying the cake plate in the end and the company luck perfect 1.5c... They were perfect most of the cups well especially so my BF ) and it s. Pictures above, but no, not too sweet…perfect for a party on Saturday morning so. Up with the frosting cake making for his birthday cover with cream cheese frosting ( the... S like the idea of putting maple syrup did you use the grating blade — haven... Perhaps the orange color convinced me to keep our appliances list light are! Though ) and it ’ s the best carrot cake at first but said yes a! My in-laws this Wednesday when they are a.ma.zing, usually moist ones how many of... Two crusts, but the consistency right ) pan bc I didn ’ t get crackers. Add 3 cups help from my mom requested carrot cake I ’ m wondering, ’... Recipe – it gave them a more carroty and less fluffy than the layers in half and some! Know we don ’ t tested baking at any altitudes because I don ’ t even need deeper to! Pound to be adjusted to avoid this and very nutty breakfast muffin that celebrates of! Said it was very proud. ) no collar, just needs another minute or two buttermilk... Recipe smitten kitchen carrot cake cupcakes and layered them sheltering in place, what s the best cake! Candied carrot coin thing from bon Appetit and it was just as written and it was just week... Into the batter & on top future celebrations of layer cake for Easter dinner it. New to this refined sugar free thing we are on a work night?!??.